The West’s only real crisis is a knowledge crisis
The enemy within – Part 2: A generation of illusions
Introduction
In the first part of this trilogy, I explored how thirty years of educational decline have eroded the foundation of our knowledge-based society. Education, once a cornerstone for cultivating critical thinking, personal responsibility, and practical skills, has increasingly morphed into a process of standardization. The result? A society that venerates diplomas whose substance has become increasingly questionable over the years. An excessive focus on equality of opportunity has flattened the landscape, trading depth for uniformity and leaving a generation ill-prepared to navigate the complexities of today’s world.
But what are the broader implications of this shift? How does a lack of expertise and craftsmanship impact our economy, stifle innovation, and weaken the social fabric? What becomes of a society where credentials are no longer a reliable marker of knowledge and competence, but instead the fuel for an ever-expanding bureaucracy that stifles creativity and encroaches on the private lives of its citizens?
In this second piece, I delve into these unsettling questions. How has thirty years of educational erosion burdened us with a generation shaped by illusions? What happens when an economy struggles with critical shortages in sectors like healthcare and engineering, while simultaneously creating jobs that exist merely to sustain bureaucratic machinery? How does an overabundance of regulations and oversight choke innovation and creativity? And how do we sustain social cohesion when polarization and atomization corrode trust in one another and in our institutions?
These are uncomfortable questions, but unavoidable ones. Is it time to admit that the path we are on leads to a dead end? And can we, before it is too late, recalibrate our priorities to break free from stagnation?
1. Bureaucracy: the silent killer of the entrepreneur
An economy thrives on the ingenuity, resilience, and creativity of its people. Growth and innovation come from those willing to adapt, take risks and push boundaries. But what happens when those qualities are systematically eroded? When education, instead of fostering critical thinking, responsibility and expertise produces graduates skilled only in navigating the system?
The consequences are clear: an economy increasingly driven by conformity stifles entrepreneurship and pushes progress to the margins.
A significant part of the problem stems from the failures of the education system. Over the years, it has produced generations equipped with credentials that overpromise and underdeliver. These graduates have learned to play by the rules, expecting success to follow naturally, without the need for effort, struggle or original thought. In a world where genuine expertise and practical skills are increasingly rare, focus shifts from creating value to maintaining processes and from maintaining processes to creating more rules. The effects are undeniable: stagnating innovation, the collapse of small businesses and an economy spinning its wheels on empty rhetoric instead of meaningful progress.
From entrepreneurship to management
Entrepreneurship demands courage, vision and the ability to defy the status quo. Yet, in a system where education prioritizes conformity over creativity, true entrepreneurs are becoming an endangered species. Taking their place is a new class of managers; people who excel at keeping systems running but lack the skills or bravery to challenge, improve, or innovate them.
Managers maintain, but they rarely create. They keep the wheels turning but do little to propel the machine forward. This pattern is evident on a larger scale: companies and governments cling to outdated structures while falling further behind in a rapidly evolving world. Stagnation becomes inevitable, and stagnation eventually leads to decline.
From management to regulation
The pitfalls of management are one thing; the real damage begins when management evolves into an obsession with regulation. In an attempt to accommodate an expanding population of degree-holders, governments have over decades generated entire industries of rule-making and enforcement. These functionaries don’t solve problems—they merely make them administratively manageable.
Rules and protocols, intended to minimize risk, come with their own cost: responsibility becomes fragmented and ownership of problems disappears. Instead of fixing issues, organizations drown in endless cycles of meetings, reports, and policies. The global financial crisis of 2008 offers a striking example: a labyrinth of financial instruments and regulatory gaps allowed risk to accumulate unchecked, creating a system so opaque that almost no one could see the full extent of the looming disaster; or act decisively to prevent it.
From regulation to decline
The real danger of a poorly educated generation isn’t their lack of knowledge, but their false confidence in what they think they know. This overconfidence has led to a culture where laws and policies are shaped by ideals, not realities. Affirmative action, for example, has placed unqualified individuals in positions of responsibility, with widespread repercussions: policies that solve nothing but create more crises, economic missteps that cost billions and an ever-expanding web of inefficiency.
“Knowledge is power, but misguided confidence breeds chaos.”
Corporate Socialism and the decimation of small businesses
The growing tide of bureaucracy spares no one, but its most devastating effects are felt by small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). Once the backbone of innovation and employment, these businesses now face a barrage of regulations designed with large corporations in mind. While multinational giants can afford compliance departments and specialized teams to meet the ever-growing list of requirements, small businesses cannot.
Take, for example, an independent bakery required to adopt fully recyclable packaging. Although the owner may support sustainability, the additional costs and reporting requirements could push the business to the brink. Or consider a restaurant owner forced to navigate a labyrinth of permits for hygiene, waste management, and labor hours; a mountain of administration that leaves little room for the actual work of running a business.
As a result, small businesses are retreating—not because they lack ambition, but because they can no longer afford to compete. Meanwhile, large corporations continue to expand, benefiting from tax breaks and access to resources that remain out of reach for smaller players. These megacorporations, often deemed "too big to fail," receive government bailouts even in cases of mismanagement or fraud and pass the cost of these interventions onto society as a whole.
The collapse of small businesses leaves behind an economy dominated by a handful of powerful players—a suffocating monoculture where innovation, diversity, and local resilience are eroded with every passing year.
Migration: a short-sighted fix
Labor shortages in critical sectors are often used to justify increased migration. Yet in practice, migration policies frequently fail to align with the specific needs of the labor market. Businesses seeking skilled international workers encounter a thicket of regulations and soaring costs, making the process both time-consuming and expensive.
At the same time, many Western countries—such as the Netherlands—operate generous asylum policies that primarily attract migrants who lack the qualifications needed to fill labor shortages. This approach places significant strain on housing and public services, amplifying dissatisfaction among local populations. While migration can play a role in addressing workforce gaps, its success hinges on policies that are realistic and targeted.
Far more critical, however, is investing in domestic talent. By aligning education with the needs of the labor market, countries can address labor shortages from within, creating a far more sustainable foundation for economic growth and resilience.
2. Innovation and progress: a future on hold
Innovation is the engine of progress. It enables us to solve problems in new ways, work more efficiently, and keep our economies competitive. But what happens when this engine sputters, held back by stifling conformity, a lack of skilled workers and an obsession with rules? The result is clear: a society increasingly reliant on subsidies and debt to maintain the illusion of growth, while real progress slows to a crawl.
How rules and protocols smother creativity
In a world as complex as ours, rules are essential, but they can easily go too far. Regulations meant to support innovation often have the opposite effect. Designed with the best of intentions—preventing misuse, ensuring fairness, leaving no one behind—they frequently lead to inefficiency, stifle creativity, and block adaptability.
Consider Europe’s CO₂ quotas, introduced as a supposed solution to climate change. Instead of fostering innovation, they’ve become an administrative nightmare, forcing companies to chase quotas rather than find real solutions. Businesses trying to comply face soaring costs and endless red tape. Meanwhile, emerging economies without these restrictions are free to expand and compete, leaving European industries behind. Germany, once a powerhouse of industrial innovation, is now feeling the crunch. Entire sectors, once vital to its economy, are on the brink of collapse. In this climate, innovation isn’t rewarded—it’s punished.
From creativity to compliance
True innovation depends on people who think creatively and challenge convention. But these traits are becoming increasingly rare. Decades of mediocre education and an overemphasis on standardization have left generations unprepared for today’s challenges. Instead of solving problems, many are trained to follow rules and stick to rigid frameworks.
This decline in creativity isn’t limited to the workplace; it’s a cultural shift. Look at the arts: original ideas have been replaced by sequels, remakes, and reboots. Even modern art often feels more provocative than meaningful. A banana duct-taped to a wall may grab headlines, but it says more about our tendency to recycle tired ideas than our ability to create something truly groundbreaking.
Businesses have adapted to this mediocrity by doubling down on standardization. Risk-taking is discouraged, and creative sparks are snuffed out before they can catch fire. The result is a future that feels predictable in all the worst ways.
“Everything that is truly great and inspiring is created by individuals who can work in freedom.”
Albert Einstein
The hidden costs of stagnation
Technological advances might suggest progress is happening. Innovations like AI, big data, and automation open doors we couldn’t have imagined a decade ago. But why doesn’t this translate into stronger economies or better lives? The issue isn’t with the technology; it’s with how we use it.
Technology is a tool, not a solution. Without an environment that fosters creativity and accountability, technology ends up masking inefficiencies rather than solving them. Automation and digital systems often streamline bureaucracy rather than improving the work itself. Innovation is reduced to cost-cutting instead of creating genuine value.
Short-term thinking makes this worse. Businesses often restrict technological advances to safe, predictable applications. In healthcare, for example, digital systems are implemented to manage paperwork, yet doctors and nurses are left with more stress and less time for patients. In manufacturing, automation boosts productivity but does little to revitalize the sector as a whole.
Choosing a new direction
Breaking out of this cycle requires more than incremental change. Real innovation thrives when the right people are empowered, when regulations support rather than stifle progress, and when we invest in creativity and responsibility over conformity and control.
The West now faces a choice: will we stick to a culture obsessed with control and risk avoidance, or will we embrace one that fosters freedom, expertise, and bold ideas?
"Technology is not a compass. It cannot guide a society that has lost its way."
3. Social cohesion, polarization, and loss of trust
A society is more than a collection of people. It is a network of free-thinking individuals who contribute to a shared future. When this network frays and individuals lose their sense of autonomy, society devolves into a fragmented crowd: a disconnected mass, bound together by shared frustrations but divided by a lack of common purpose. In such an environment, mistrust and alienation thrive, eroding the cohesion that holds communities together.
The disappearing art of nuance and critical thinking
Critical thinking is the cornerstone of a free and functioning society. It allows people to navigate complexity, discern fact from fiction, and find balanced solutions to difficult problems. Without it, societies fall prey to oversimplification. Public discourse becomes binary, reducing debates to rigid positions dominated by emotional outbursts and propaganda.
The consequences are stark: dialogue is replaced by confrontation, polarization deepens, and collaboration becomes increasingly rare. Instead of bridging divides and working toward solutions, societies amplify differences, creating an environment where stagnation and division prevail.
Migration and its pressure on cohesion
Migration is often positioned as a solution to labor shortages, but in many Western countries, the reality is more complex. A significant proportion of migrants arrive not as skilled workers, but as asylum seekers or through other pathways disconnected from labor market needs. While humanitarian considerations are essential, these migration flows often exacerbate existing pressures on infrastructure and resources.
The effects ripple across key areas of society. Housing prices soar, as demand outpaces supply. Schools struggle to integrate large numbers of students who often face significant knowledge gaps, while social security systems buckle under the growing strain. For communities already facing economic challenges, migration is less often seen as a benefit and more as a source of disruption and loss of control.
This strain is compounded by the perception of unequal treatment. Many citizens feel that governments prioritize the needs of newcomers over those of existing residents. This perception fuels mistrust and alienation, undermining the shared sense of fairness that is essential for social cohesion.
Mistrust and the erosion of institutions
The growing mistrust in institutions stems from a widening gap between governments and their citizens. Where institutions were once seen as protectors of public welfare, they are now viewed as out-of-touch bureaucracies that fail to deliver.
Tax burdens increase, yet affordable housing remains scarce. Healthcare systems are stretched to breaking point, while political decisions seem increasingly disconnected from the everyday concerns of citizens. Many people feel powerless, convinced that no matter how they vote or protest, the system remains unresponsive.
This erosion of trust is further exacerbated by a lack of transparency and accountability within institutions. Governments appear more focused on self-preservation through endless rule-making than on addressing public concerns. The fallout is severe: as institutional trust collapses, so does the social stability it underpins.
Conclusion
The social impacts of poor education, misguided migration policies, and failing institutions are far-reaching. A society that loses its capacity for nuance and responsibility becomes a society fractured by mistrust and division. Without trust in one another and in the systems meant to serve us, social cohesion unravels—and without cohesion, no society can truly thrive.
The pressing question is whether this downward spiral can be reversed. Can we rekindle the values and structures that once fostered progress, innovation, and unity? In the third and final part of this series, we will explore whether the foundations of our society can still be saved—and what it will take to break free from the cycles of stagnation and division.
Has this sparked your curiosity? I've authored a successful fiction novel depicting life in a totalitarian state founded on radical equality. The novel is being translated into English and will be released in the coming months. Meanwhile, if you're interested in receiving more articles offering new perspectives on contemporary topics, sign up!
For my dutch readers:
Het promoten van een boek is een avontuurlijke zoektocht. Ik heb inmiddels talloze routes verkend en meerdere platforms uitgeprobeerd, maar uiteindelijk voel ik mij bij Substack toch het meest thuis.
Daarom heb ik mijn Nederlandse Substack voor Curlingkinderen nieuw leven ingeblazen! Hier post ik dezelfde artikelen in het Nederlands, voor iedereen die liever in de eigen taal leest. Benieuwd? Klik op de knop hieronder om het Nederlandse artikel te lezen. En als je je inschrijft, ontvang je het eerste hoofdstuk van mijn superspannende thriller direct gratis in je inbox.